5 Best Kitchen Countertops For a Rental Property in 2024

Last Updated: February 2024

Selecting the right kitchen countertop for a rental property is a balancing act of durability, cost, maintenance, and aesthetics. Landlords and property managers seek building materials that can withstand the wear and tear of various tenants while still maintaining a fresh and appealing look. Among the many options, certain materials stand out for their ability to meet these diverse needs, offering a blend of resilience, ease of care, and visual appeal.

Best Types of Rental Property Kitchen Countertops

Best OverallBest EconomyBest DurabilityBest PremiumBest Design

Solid Surface





Below we explore the top 5 kitchen countertops for rental properties based on 5 different factors that landlords and property managers should consider when determining which type of kitchen countertop is best for their rental property investment.

Best Overall

Solid Surface

  • Durability: Resistant to most damages and can be easily repaired if scratched or chipped.
  • Maintenance: Non-porous and easy to clean, but can be sensitive to heat.
  • Cost: Mid-range pricing, more affordable than natural stone.
  • Aesthetic: Offers a seamless appearance and comes in various colors and patterns.
Why We Like Solid Surface Countertops

Experts often praise solid surface countertops for their seamless integration and wide range of design options, making them a top choice for rental properties. They offer a perfect blend of functionality and style, appealing to both landlords and tenants for their durability and aesthetic versatility.

Best Economy


  • Durability: Laminate is reasonably durable and resists stains and scratches.
  • Maintenance: It’s easy to clean and doesn’t require sealing.
  • Cost: Laminate is one of the most affordable countertop materials.
  • Aesthetic: Available in various colors and patterns, including those that mimic more expensive materials.
Why We Like Laminate Countertops

Laminate countertops are lauded for their cost-effectiveness and surprisingly stylish appearance, often mimicking more expensive building products. They are favored in the rental market for their low maintenance and variety of color and pattern options, providing an economical yet attractive solution.

Best Durability


  • Durability: Extremely durable and non-porous, resisting stains and scratches.
  • Maintenance: Low maintenance, doesn’t require sealing.
  • Cost: On the higher end, but its durability can make it a cost-effective choice in the long term.
  • Aesthetic: Available in a wide range of colors and patterns.
Why We Like Quartz Countertops

Quartz countertops receive high marks for their exceptional durability and non-porous surface, making them a resilient choice for high-traffic kitchens. Their ease of maintenance and resistance to stains and scratches make them a preferred option for rental properties where longevity and minimal upkeep are key.

Best Premium


  • Durability: Granite is very hard and scratch-resistant.
  • Maintenance: Requires sealing periodically, but is otherwise easy to clean.
  • Cost: More expensive than laminate, but less than some other natural stones.
  • Aesthetic: Offers a high-end look that can increase the rental property’s appeal.
Why We Like Granite Countertops

Granite countertops are often celebrated for their unique beauty and the luxurious touch they add to any kitchen space. Their robustness and high-end appeal make them a sought-after choice for premium rental properties, offering both durability and elegance.

Best Design


  • Durability: Ceramic and porcelain tiles are durable and heat resistant.
  • Maintenance: Grout lines can be a challenge to keep clean.
  • Cost: Generally affordable, depending on the type of tile.
  • Aesthetic: Highly customizable in terms of design and color.
Why We Like Tile Countertops

Tile countertops are frequently admired for their customizable design potential, allowing for unique and creative kitchen aesthetics. They stand out in rental properties for their ability to offer a personalized touch and a wide range of style options, from classic to contemporary.

Disclosure: RentalRealEstate.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program as well as other affiliate programs, designed to provide a means for us to generate revenue by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites at no extra cost to you.

Rental Property Kitchen Countertop FAQ

How Do the Different Countertops Compare to Each other?

When selecting kitchen countertops for rental properties, landlords and property managers must weigh various factors including cost, durability, maintenance, and aesthetic appeal. The following table provides a detailed comparison of popular countertop materials,:

MaterialCostDurabilityMaintenanceHeat ResistanceScratch ResistanceTenant Appeal
LaminateLow initial cost, low long-term costModerateLow (easy to clean, no sealing required)LowModerateHigh
GraniteHigh initial cost, moderate long-term costHighModerate (requires periodic sealing)HighHighHigh
QuartzHigh initial cost, low long-term costVery HighLow (no sealing, easy to clean)HighVery HighVery High
Solid SurfaceModerate initial cost, low long-term costModerateLow (easy to repair, easy to clean)ModerateLowHigh
TileModerate initial cost, moderate long-term costHigh (tiles), Low (grout)High (grout cleaning)HighHigh (tiles), Low (grout)Moderate

Kitchen Countertop Installation

Where to Find a Rental Property Kitchen Countertop Installer?

Finding qualified, honest, and reliable service pros can easily be done with online service directories. These platforms directly connect customers and service providers who can do repairs from garbage disposals to built-in microwaves.

How to Find the Balance of High-Quality Materials vs a Limited Renovation Budget?

To balance quality and budget, landlords often opt for materials like laminate or solid surface countertops, which offer a good mix of durability and style at a lower cost. Laminate, in particular, provides a wide range of designs and is surprisingly resilient, making it a cost-effective choice without compromising too much on aesthetics. Additionally, investing in slightly higher-priced materials during a rental property construction project like quartz can be cost-effective in the long run due to its durability and minimal maintenance requirements.

Which Countertop Materials are Universally Appealing to a Wide Range of Potential Tenants?

To appeal to a wide range of tenants, selecting neutral and timeless countertop materials like quartz or granite is advisable, as they offer both durability and a universally appealing aesthetic. These materials come in various colors and patterns, ensuring that they can fit into any kitchen design, from modern to traditional. Additionally, solid surface countertops are also a versatile choice, as they can mimic natural stone or other high-end materials, providing a sophisticated look that appeals to most tenants.

More Rental Property Building Products

Home » Construction » Ultimate List & Guide to Rental Property Building Products » 5 Best Kitchen Countertops For a Rental Property in 2024